Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
MyECU main site
  Welcome to our forum.
  HomeHelpSearchLoginRegister  
 
Pages: 1 2 3 4 
Send Topic Print
In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder? (Read 42843 times)
raz
Senior Member
****
Offline


Guzzi 11OO Sport, My16MkV,
Innovate LC-1

Posts: 373
Stockholm, Sweden
Gender: male
Re: In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder?
Reply #45 - 09/22/10 at 01:23:19
 
Luhbo wrote on 09/21/10 at 21:08:06:
raz wrote on 09/21/10 at 06:31:50:
...With individual cylinder mapping, the closed loop will compensate for the TB imbalance ....


I don't think it's a good idea to try to balance the flap angles using the lambda probes. I'd even say that's a rather bad idea.

Then we are in agreement, because that is just what I said. Disable closed loop in order to *avoid* this!  Smiley
Back to top
 

59° North
1100 Sport iniezione elettronica -- the perfect merge of a superbike and a steam train
 
IP Logged
 
Luhbo
Full Member
***
Offline


I Like My15M!

Posts: 186
Germany
Re: In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder?
Reply #46 - 09/22/10 at 18:34:36
 
Come on, you're too clever to make postings like that, aren't you.

How should any offset map affect the throttle balancing? At least as long as you stick to the standard procedure using pressure gauges or similar stuff.

Or, puting the same question in the most simple form: what should those poor OEM equipment users do, still out there in large numbers, if it comes to throttle balancing?

Hubert
Back to top
« Last Edit: 09/22/10 at 18:36:06 by Luhbo »  
 
IP Logged
 
COnewbie
Full Member
***
Offline


97 Sport1100i My16M MkVII
2 LC-1s

Posts: 120
Central Oregon, USA
Gender: male
Re: In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder?
Reply #47 - 09/23/10 at 01:48:06
 
As a retired Standards Laboratory Engineer, I have to agree with raz.  In order to insure that the TB's are synchronised, you have to eliminate other means of compensation (the CylOffs table, and O2 sensor inputs).  Once that is adjusted as closely as possible, the O2 sensor(s) will "fine tune" any minor imbalances by means of the CylOffs table.  When I reversed the O2 inputs on my bike, the CylOffs table started to show large values.  I followed raz's advice, then put the O2 inputs back in proper order, set the O2 sensor input back to "both", and now the CylOffs table shows only small values.
Back to top
 

44 1/2 degrees North,  1036m up.
 
IP Logged
 
Luhbo
Full Member
***
Offline


I Like My15M!

Posts: 186
Germany
Re: In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder?
Reply #48 - 09/23/10 at 02:18:16
 
Okay then, don't want to argue with you and first of all not in this forum, nevertheless I'd most welcome it if you could go a little bit more into detail and explain to a still active engineer how this offset map will affect the pressure readings shown by two pressure gauges attached to the left/right throttle body.

Thanks.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
COnewbie
Full Member
***
Offline


97 Sport1100i My16M MkVII
2 LC-1s

Posts: 120
Central Oregon, USA
Gender: male
Re: In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder?
Reply #49 - 09/23/10 at 04:46:17
 
OK, Not to argue, but to do a better job of explaining, (RAZ, correct me if I'm wrong!), here are the details as I understand them.  The O2 sensor(s) are the input to the ECU so it can adjust the AFR by changing the Injector Duration.  CylOffs is that compensation for the right cylinder.  When you change the AFR, it affects how that cylinder performs, and it will change the intake vacuum at the specific RPM where you are adjusting.  The pressure gauge attached to that cylinder will then show the compensated vacuum pressure.  This works, but as the TB's get more and more out of sync over time, more and more compensation has to be applied.  Since the engine is operating closed loop, you may or may not notice the difference, it's just a matter of procedural correctness.  I hope I did a good job of explaining the details. Smiley
Back to top
 

44 1/2 degrees North,  1036m up.
 
IP Logged
 
Luhbo
Full Member
***
Offline


I Like My15M!

Posts: 186
Germany
Re: In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder?
Reply #50 - 09/23/10 at 05:22:55
 
My opinion is that both cylinders are running at the same rpm, always Wink Next thesis is that the resulting manifold pressure is a function of mainly rpm and flap opening/throttle (all other things like valve size, - opening, cams, pipes etc. should be held constant for now).
At this point I see two ways to go on. One is that we have just a different understanding of what "balancing the throttle bodies" means, the other one is that you or Raz believe that a tiny drop or two of fuel will significantly change the as above mentioned resulting pressure in the manifold.

Hubert
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
raz
Senior Member
****
Offline


Guzzi 11OO Sport, My16MkV,
Innovate LC-1

Posts: 373
Stockholm, Sweden
Gender: male
Re: In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder?
Reply #51 - 09/23/10 at 05:23:13
 
Luhbo wrote on 09/22/10 at 18:34:36:
Or, puting the same question in the most simple form: what should those poor OEM equipment users do, still out there in large numbers, if it comes to throttle balancing?

I'm not sure I understand your point. The OEM users already run open loop so they can just hook up the manometers and sync it. I can too, running open loop or not. But COnewbie should disable closed loop because he has two sensors. I may be wrong, it's just a gut feeling.

COnewbie wrote on 09/23/10 at 04:46:17:
RAZ, correct me if I'm wrong!

I think you got what I meant but like I said, I'm not sure we are right. After all, the vacuum is produced by the rotating engine, more or less regardless of individual A/F's. Maybe this is how you see it, Luhbo?

An extreme example would be this: Sync your TB's. Then kill one of the cylinders, eg. pulling the wire from its injector. Now, are the TB's still in sync while the engine is running on only one cylinder? I can't believe it would be.

I just imagine that if you have imbalance (i.e. a mechanical imbalance), the individual closed loop can compensate a little for it, and this will make real (mechanical) sync harder. Maybe this is not much of an issue, but one thing I'm 100% sure of: Syncing in open loop will not hurt.
Back to top
 

59° North
1100 Sport iniezione elettronica -- the perfect merge of a superbike and a steam train
 
IP Logged
 
Luhbo
Full Member
***
Offline


I Like My15M!

Posts: 186
Germany
Re: In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder?
Reply #52 - 09/23/10 at 05:46:56
 
Raz, that's indeed what I want to say.
Nevertheless the experiment you give is a bit off - because it's just too extreme. You can't by no means compare the effects of a dead cylinder with those of one getting just 2 or 5% more fuel.
Oh, and you know that I think flashing a different map just for balancing the TBs does hurt, don't you? Wink

Hubert
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
raz
Senior Member
****
Offline


Guzzi 11OO Sport, My16MkV,
Innovate LC-1

Posts: 373
Stockholm, Sweden
Gender: male
Re: In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder?
Reply #53 - 09/23/10 at 05:58:37
 
I tend to think of extremes in order to understand smaller things but maybe that was too extreme  Smiley

The more I think of it, the more I believe you are right. If it's an issue at all, it's probably academic.
Back to top
 

59° North
1100 Sport iniezione elettronica -- the perfect merge of a superbike and a steam train
 
IP Logged
 
greenmonster
Full Member
***
Offline


Sweden

Posts: 196
Re: In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder?
Reply #54 - 09/23/10 at 10:08:05
 

Just guessing:

Wouldn`t two cylinders w almost identical A/F
( meaning Cylofs active)
create the closest to similar pressure on the piston and therefore have very even MAP?
Back to top
 

Ducati 907IE  MyECU P8
 
IP Logged
 
COnewbie
Full Member
***
Offline


97 Sport1100i My16M MkVII
2 LC-1s

Posts: 120
Central Oregon, USA
Gender: male
Re: In My16M, which O2 input is left cylinder?
Reply #55 - 09/24/10 at 08:25:13
 
I believe you're right, but with this caveat:
If both TB's have the same opening, and all four valves are adjusted exactly spot on, then both cylinders (assuming perfect sealing of the piston rings), will have the same A/F, and CylOffs would be expected to show 0 throughout the CylOffs map.  The reason I mentioned the valves is because the valve lash affects the timing of the intake and exhaust cycles.  Less lash makes the timing earlier, and more lash makes it later, which can affect the A/F if there is overlap with InjDur or SpkAdv.  That's MY guess!  Smiley
Back to top
 

44 1/2 degrees North,  1036m up.
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 3 4 
Send Topic Print