Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
MyECU main site
  Welcome to our forum.
  HomeHelpSearchLoginRegister  
 
Pages: 1 ... 3 4 5 6 
Send Topic Print
Ducati and MyP8 (Read 62622 times)
996SPS
Junior Member
**
Offline


ducati with P8

Posts: 60
Finland
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #60 - 06/20/13 at 16:29:44
 
Thank you very much Hubert and Rick for your ideas and views. This is the kind of feedback I am looking for.

I do not have the Lambda connected right now, but I will soon (again).

Looking at the values of Hubert's map, I would say that I am in the ballpark, maybe max. +/-50% difference at some points or values. That's what is strange. How picky can this machine be? I mean, if the  map is anywhere near running state, why doesn't my bike even try to run?

Or does everything have to be spot on to get it running? I hope not. I do not have the time and nerves for that.

@Cliff:

One thing that comes to mind; how can I increase the spark with the CoilCharge -value (and also be sure not to fry the coils)? maybe if the spark isn't strong enough and due to the fact that compression is quite high, it's not starting. Just an idea...

At the end of the video I posted, where the bike starts, that is where the original ECU is used.


I am putting a new set of used coils to my bike today, to see if that cures the problem of running on one cylinder intermittently(with the original ECU). After this I can again concentrate on MyP8.

And during the weekend, I hope to get to a track again!
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Luhbo
Full Member
***
Offline


I Like My15M!

Posts: 186
Germany
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #61 - 06/20/13 at 20:26:49
 
Anytime, Marko.
I read also Rick's comments, I still don't agree with him.
Starting is managed by two parameters: the "TDC=1" option and the line "Prime" at its actual temperature point. Having the Prime line matching the engine will respond, or 'jump' as we say, regardless what values are in the idle line. His engine doesn't, so the Prime value is not correct. Try it 2 times (short bursts), then increase the number by 1 or 2. Repeat. Try starting 2x, increase, repeat. It works that way.
In case you think you've drowned it hold the throttle open. If this gives a response then reduce the former increased figure.
That's how it works with working equipment.

Make clear what injectors your bike has and how the OEM triggers them. What is their flow rate? Do you have any figures? At what system pressure?

Make sure the rest of the bike works and also that the ecu is built up correctly. I've seen you've run into some problems during the assembly phase. These are all corrected?

Hubert
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Rickf4
YaBB Newbies
*
Offline


I love MyECU!

Posts: 30
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #62 - 06/21/13 at 00:37:21
 
Hi Guys, I don't disagree with you Hubert but we a have a different way of doing things, and if they get the job done, that's fine by me. I think Marko needs to find what works for him.

For sure don't want to start a big discussion on this forum...

For me prime pulse is just one phase of starting as above 500rpm the ecu reverts back to the map so that why my opinion that you need good values on your idle positions so you know you have one problem and not multiple. That is  why I say is easier to sort your idle when the bike is hot and the start to work on your enrichment's over time. You know the bike runs and how much fuel it needs to idle.


Sorting the starts without knowing if the bike runs properly doesn't make sense to me but again different heads have different ways of seeing things...

I had a close look at the video the bike starts for a fraction and the dies. The reason the bike died in my opinion is not the prime pulse.

Actually in my view there are six parts of map that contribute to reliable starts and work on different parts of the starting procedure. You have to be methodical adjusting all these values.
The ones you say plus the 500 row,idle row, the after start enrichment and the permanent choke. Cool
On my bike, I had to modify all this parts so bike doesn't die after 20 seconds...

Hubert, your procedure makes sense, but I've tried that and doesn't work for me.
If you think why you need a prime pulse in starting an engine, you will see your procedure may work on many occasions but not all...

When I tried something like you describe, I would get the bike to start, and think to myself, yes! nailed it, only to try to start the bike next day and fail! Grin

The prime pulse need to be so big, first off all to compensate for any air in the fuel system, and because most of the fuel isn't burned when the intake and the valves are cold. These parts are cold and the fuel forms droplets that doesn't mix with air so to compensate this...
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Rickf4
YaBB Newbies
*
Offline


I love MyECU!

Posts: 30
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #63 - 06/21/13 at 01:03:21
 
continuation of the first post...  Cheesy

,you need loads of fuel... After the first prime pulse, you  get fuel condensation and it tends to stick to the walls of the intake and your prime pulse will be different next time you try. In my view you only have one chance a day to get this value correct, when you don't have any fuel on the intake.

Very time consuming but it's the only way that I get repeatable results on my bike. Maybe my bike is more sensitive to fuel mixture as it is a 4 cylinder wasted spark.

Now be careful with cranking your bike like crazy. On ducs that only leads to sprag clutch failure, and again I talk from experience. Me and my brother have 5 ducatis in the family.

For sure check your hardware  but you had your my ecu running on a previous video. That was single injector right?

Marko, you will need to get the nerves!

If you think all the troubles me and cliff had just to make my ecu run! Something like 20 or more firmware revisions, ignition driver failure, injection driver failure, first it dint rev at all, then 4k, then 10k, next new 16mhz firmware, work well on the test bench, didn't past 3k on the bike. It was a nightmare and sometimes I just thought to myself, just forget about it, but now I have a working unit. 

Cliff and I continued moving forward with the project and was the genesis of the mark7 edition of the My16.

You need to be methodical and take you time.

Good luck with your work!

Cheers

Ricardo
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
996SPS
Junior Member
**
Offline


ducati with P8

Posts: 60
Finland
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #64 - 06/21/13 at 02:16:31
 
Thanks again for both of you for your posts.

About the injectors; they are IW724 and flow according to data found on the net is somewhere in the region of 300cc/min. Pressure in the fuel system is if I remember correctly, 3bar. (or was it 3,5 bar?)

About the ECU itself; Yes, I had some soldering errors on it, but they are fixed and I hope that's the end of that. Everything is possible of course..

The reason for me trying to start this bike cold is that basically you can do it only once a day (to test the cold starting features). then you have to wait a long time before everything is cool again.

I understand the two ways of methods offered her to tackle my problems and in a way, both are right.

Maybe I should get it idling perfectly when warm and then try to do the same when cold.

I will definitely report back here when ever I do something and report any logs videos and findings..
If I would be doing all this on my own, I would have given up long time ago..

My history with this bike starts in september 2005, when I bought it from Germany with 19000 km on it. it now has almost 65000 km on it.

I have had so many mechanical and electrical problems with this bike during the past 8 years that a person with a shorter fuse would have sold/dismembered the bike LOOONG time ago.

unfortunaltey my old blog dissappeared in to byte-heaven.. there I had reported all sorts of findings and such along the way.

every time I thought I figured out some problem and got it fixed, another problem popped up. Now the latest is this running on one cylinder. It has done it many years, but usually only 1-2 times a summer and always a very short time, max 30 sec. now last saturday, it happened again and I had to ride 50 km's, more than 30 minutes on/off/on/off with 1/2 cylinders.. frustrating to say the least.

now I am off to put the new coils to it and tomorrow I will test ride.

Thanks all..
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Luhbo
Full Member
***
Offline


I Like My15M!

Posts: 186
Germany
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #65 - 06/21/13 at 03:01:58
 
So it's this one:
http://www.bikesportdevelopments.co.uk/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=IW724

It's obviously also taken for the 4 valve Guzzis - one per side only. If you have them hard wired in parallel it's an interesting configuration I'd say. Can't say if half the on-time really does the trick. At least it's for sure not what Marelli/Ducati once had in mind when they did the layout.

@ Ricardo
You say 'cranking like crazy'. Then how often can one start his Ducati before the starter mechanism gets busted? 1x per 100 km oder so? ^^

Hubert
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
996SPS
Junior Member
**
Offline


ducati with P8

Posts: 60
Finland
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #66 - 06/25/13 at 17:10:08
 
Nothing much to report, other than I almost burned my bike on friday while test riding with the new coils.. Had a split in the fuel line above the rear cylinder.  Shocked

Sunday I was on a race track. Perfect weather.

I hope to get back to MyP8 testing this week.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
996SPS
Junior Member
**
Offline


ducati with P8

Posts: 60
Finland
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #67 - 07/04/13 at 05:15:43
 
Aaaand the running on one cylinder is back... $hit.

Going to change the ignition modules next.

Question to Cliff:

Do the ignition modules need to be used with MyP8?
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
YaBB Administrator
YaBB Administrator
*****
Offline


I love YaBB!

Posts: 679
The Land of YaBB
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #68 - 07/04/13 at 06:31:20
 
The early versions of the MyP8 had the capability to  drive coils directly but as the feature was never used I removed it.

This lack of spark is on a running engine or you're not seeing spark while trying to start the bike?
Back to top
 

The Administrator.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
996SPS
Junior Member
**
Offline


ducati with P8

Posts: 60
Finland
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #69 - 07/04/13 at 16:00:30
 
This running on one cylinder -problem is with the original ECU. Has been with me for several years, on and off every now and then,

Haven't done anything with the MyP8 in weeks...  Embarrassed
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Luhbo
Full Member
***
Offline


I Like My15M!

Posts: 186
Germany
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #70 - 07/04/13 at 19:50:21
 
Before you start swapping all those expensive parts one after the other you could try to add some extra cables in parallel to the existing harness. Maybe it's just a problem with the cables or - even worse - with the connectors.

Hubert
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
996SPS
Junior Member
**
Offline


ducati with P8

Posts: 60
Finland
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #71 - 07/05/13 at 16:02:08
 
Thanks for the tip Hubert.

Lucky me the modules are not very expensive.. at least the alternatives. I bet the original ducati/weber marelli part is.

I'll be updating my blog on findings and progress whenever something happens.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
YaBB Administrator
YaBB Administrator
*****
Offline


I love YaBB!

Posts: 679
The Land of YaBB
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #72 - 07/05/13 at 16:41:32
 
If you wanted to do away with the modules altogether it wouldn't be a big job to add add a couple of FETs inside the ECU to do the job. ( and rewire the modules out )
You'd want to be sure you've identified the problem first.
Back to top
 

The Administrator.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Luhbo
Full Member
***
Offline


I Like My15M!

Posts: 186
Germany
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #73 - 07/05/13 at 20:35:12
 
Checked your blog: the new ones obviously weren't that cheap Sad
Instead you might just swap the existing ones, front to back I mean. If you say the rear cylinder gets off from time to time, then after swapping the suspect parts the front one should show these symptoms.

Hubert
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
996SPS
Junior Member
**
Offline


ducati with P8

Posts: 60
Finland
Re: Ducati and MyP8
Reply #74 - 07/05/13 at 21:26:47
 
I am not sure if it is the rear cylinder every time that is acting up. there is no way of checking it while riding.
Long time ago, when this happened, I had just started the bike and I was at a petrol station, I could feel the exhaust and that was when I knew it was the rear cylinder.

I have found another alternative for the marelli ignition module. I will test it and if it works, I will get also another and be done with it. It was 21 EUR.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 ... 3 4 5 6 
Send Topic Print